The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission's push to bring crypto perpetual futures into regulated markets is facing resistance from Wall Street after its May authorization of Bitcoin perpetual futures, Coinpaper reported. The publication said the approval extended a trading model that had previously been concentrated on offshore cryptocurrency platforms.
Established derivatives operators objected to the Bitcoin approval, according to Coinpaper. The publication said major exchanges warn that highly leveraged contracts could expose investors to sudden liquidations and contribute to instability across the broader market. CME Group and a coalition involving Cboe Global Markets and Citadel Securities are among those challenging the regulator's approach, Coinpaper reported.
Approvals draw exchange objections
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig announced on November 3 that qualifying US exchanges could begin trading perpetual futures tied to individual stocks, Coinpaper reported. The announcement followed the May Bitcoin authorization, extending a trading model that the publication said had previously been concentrated on offshore cryptocurrency platforms.
CME Group and a coalition that includes Cboe Global Markets and Citadel Securities are challenging the regulator's approach, according to Coinpaper. They argue that existing futures rules may not adequately address the risks presented by the products, the publication reported. Their challenge comes as major exchanges warn about both investor liquidations and potential effects on the wider market, according to Coinpaper.
CME contends that perpetual contracts resemble swaps because they involve recurring funding payments and lack conventional settlement dates, Coinpaper reported. Those payments are intended to keep contract prices aligned with underlying markets, according to the publication. Coinpaper said swaps generally face different requirements covering capital, reporting and collateral.
Coinpaper reported that CME's earlier legal challenge has become part of a wider dispute over the investor protections applied to cryptocurrency-style products. That dispute follows objections from established derivatives operators to the CFTC's Bitcoin futures approval in May, according to the publication. The disagreement over crypto perpetual futures includes whether the rules used for existing futures adequately address the products' risks, Coinpaper said.
How crypto perpetual futures work
A perpetual contract has no fixed expiration date, unlike a traditional future, Coinpaper reported. Positions can remain open without a set end date if traders meet margin rules and make regular funding payments, which are intended to align contract prices with the underlying market, according to the publication.
Those features have helped make perpetual futures popular with cryptocurrency traders, according to Coinpaper. The publication said the products appeal in particular to traders seeking leveraged exposure without repeatedly renewing contracts that expire. The ability to maintain a position remains subject to the margin requirements and funding payments described by the publication.
Crypto perpetual futures can amplify gains and losses because leverage lets traders control positions larger than their initial collateral, Coinpaper reported. The publication said traders can use the contracts to seek leveraged exposure without repeatedly renewing expiring positions. That relationship between collateral and market exposure is central to the concerns raised by exchanges about highly leveraged contracts, according to the publication.
In an example provided by Coinpaper, a trader posting $1,000 at 20-times leverage obtains $20,000 in market exposure. An adverse price move of roughly 5% could exhaust the initial margin before fees and maintenance requirements, the publication said. The example illustrates how crypto perpetual futures can produce losses against a position much larger than the collateral initially posted.
Liquidation and leverage risks
When collateral falls below required levels, a trading platform may automatically close a position to limit further losses, Coinpaper reported. The publication said forced selling can also intensify market declines, potentially creating feedback loops like those seen in previous Bitcoin liquidation waves. For crypto perpetual futures traders using leverage, Coinpaper said a relatively small adverse move can exhaust initial margin before fees and maintenance requirements.
The possibility of sudden liquidations is among the concerns major exchanges have raised about the CFTC's push, according to Coinpaper. The publication reported that the exchanges also warn of broader market instability from highly leveraged contracts. Coinpaper described automatic closures as a way to limit further losses on a position, while reporting that forced selling can add to a market decline.
CME CEO Terry Duffy has repeatedly warned about leverage, Coinpaper reported. Duffy argues that less experienced traders could face greater risks if access to perpetual contracts is expanded, according to the publication. Coinpaper also reported that established derivatives operators objected after the Bitcoin approval, while CME and the coalition questioned whether existing futures rules adequately address the products' risks.
Trading access for crypto perpetual futures
Supporters of US supervision argue that bringing perpetual contracts under domestic oversight offers stronger transparency and customer protections than leaving trading concentrated offshore, Coinpaper reported. The publication said the regulatory expansion also creates opportunities for newer financial platforms. The CFTC's May authorization extended a model that had previously been concentrated on offshore cryptocurrency platforms, according to Coinpaper.
Kalshi has entered the regulated perpetual futures market, while Coinbase continues to expand its US derivatives infrastructure, Coinpaper reported. The publication said Coinbase's expansion follows the approval of its clearinghouse. Coinpaper identified the two companies' moves as part of the opportunities for newer financial platforms created by the regulatory expansion.
Webull has announced plans to offer crypto perpetual futures using Kalshi's infrastructure, according to Coinpaper. The publication said the plan could broaden retail access to the products as established derivatives operators challenge the regulator's approach. Kalshi has already moved into regulated perpetual futures, Coinpaper reported, while Webull's offering remains a plan.
Conclusion
The CFTC's May authorization of Bitcoin perpetual futures drew objections from established derivatives operators, while its later announcement covered contracts tied to individual stocks, Coinpaper reported. The publication said CME and a coalition involving Cboe and Citadel are challenging the regulator's approach, with exchanges warning about leverage and liquidations. Supporters argue US oversight offers stronger transparency and customer protections than offshore trading, according to Coinpaper. As the dispute continues, Webull has announced plans to introduce cryptocurrency perpetual futures through Kalshi's infrastructure, a step the publication said could broaden retail access.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the CFTC approve for Bitcoin perpetual futures in May?
The CFTC authorized Bitcoin perpetual futures in May, Coinpaper reported. The publication said the authorization drew objections from established derivatives operators. On November 3, Selig announced that perpetual contracts linked to individual stocks could also trade on US exchanges that qualify, according to Coinpaper.
Why is CME challenging the CFTC's approach to perpetual futures?
CME's earlier legal challenge is part of a broader dispute over investor protections for cryptocurrency-style products, according to Coinpaper. The publication said swaps generally face different capital, reporting and collateral requirements, and that CME is challenging whether existing futures rules adequately address the products' risks.
How can 20-times leverage affect a perpetual futures position?
At 20-times leverage, $1,000 in collateral can provide $20,000 in market exposure, according to an example reported by Coinpaper. The publication said an adverse price move of roughly 5% could exhaust the initial margin before fees and maintenance requirements.
What are Webull's plans for cryptocurrency perpetual futures?
Webull has announced plans to introduce cryptocurrency perpetual futures through Kalshi's infrastructure, Coinpaper reported. The publication said the plan could broaden retail access. Kalshi has already moved into regulated perpetual futures, according to the publication.
Sources
Read Also
